← All Books fairy tale Chapter Book Fully Reviewed

Fairest of All (Whatever After #1)

by Sarah Mlynowski · Whatever After #1

A clever fairy tale portal adventure that hooks reluctant readers and reimagines Snow White with girl power

Kid
67
Parent
55
Teacher
63
Best fit: ages Ages 8-10 Still works: ages Ages 7-11 Lexile 400L

The story

When ten-year-old Abby and her younger brother Jonah are magically transported through their basement mirror into the Snow White fairy tale, they accidentally change the story and must find a way to give Snow her happy ending while racing to get home before morning.

Age verdict

Best at ages 8-10 (grades 3-4). Accessible for strong 7-year-olds, enjoyable through age 11, but may feel too light for readers 12 and up.

Our take

Kid-engagement gateway: strong hook and momentum with accessible fairy-tale premise, moderate literary depth, strongest as a reading-habit builder

What stands out

Each audience's top 3 dimensions. Out of 30 scored per book.

👦

Kids love

  • First-chapter grab Strong

    Comparable to Lunch Lady and the Cyborg Substitute — Opens with immediate intrigue and direct address ('Then the mirror in our basement ate us'), establishing distinctive voice. Sits at because voice hook strength matches anchor.

  • Middle momentum Strong

    Off the Hook — Every chapter end creates unresolved tension; nested problem-solving prevents narrative stalling. Sits at because relentless momentum is comparable to reference.

👩

Parents love

  • Reading gateway Strong

    Comparable to A Bear Called Paddington — 169 pages, 400L Lexile, conversational voice, short chapters with cliffhangers, fairy tale premise lowering fantasy barrier. Sits at because gateway effectiveness equals anchor—converts reluctant readers.

  • Stereotype-breaker Strong

    Comparable to A Snicker of Magic — Snow actively saves prince via knowledge and action, not waiting for kiss. Abby defined by logic and judge aspiration. Diverse dwarf household. Sits at because stereotype-breaking is systematic and intentional.

🍎

Teachers love

  • Reluctant reader rescue Exceptional

    Hard Luck — At 169 pages with 400L Lexile, immediate engaging voice, adventure by chapter 5, familiar fairy tale frame—exceptional reluctant reader pick. More accessible than most chapter books. Sits at because reluctant-reader rescue effectiveness matches highest tier.

  • Read-aloud power Strong

    Comparable to The Golem's Eye — First-person conversational voice reads naturally aloud. Mirror-swallowing dramatic, character voices (Evil Evelyn's theatricality, Snow's formality) are performable. Sits at because read-aloud power is strong.

✓ Perfect for

  • Reluctant readers ages 8-10 who need a short, fast-paced hook
  • Kids who love fairy tales and want to see them reimagined
  • Readers who enjoy portal fantasies and what-if premises
  • Girls looking for a smart, logical female protagonist

Not ideal for

Readers seeking deep emotional complexity, rich vocabulary building, or real-world learning — this prioritizes entertainment and accessibility over literary ambition

⚠ Heads up

Death

At a glance

Pages
169
Chapters
25
Words
30k
Lexile
400L
Difficulty
Easy
POV
First Person
Illustration
None
Published
2012
Publisher
Scholastic Press
ISBN
9780545855761

Mood & style

Tone: Adventurous Pacing: Steady Clip Weight: Moderate Tension: Emotional Stakes Humor: Situational Humor: Gentle Wit

You'll know it worked when…

A child who finishes this book and immediately asks 'Is there a second one?' is ready for the full 17-book Whatever After series.

More like this

Same genre, similar age range. Ranked by kid score.

Want more picks like this?

Get 5 hand-picked book reviews for your child's age — one email a month.