← All Books fantasy Middle Grade Novel Fully Reviewed

Twice Upon a Time

by James Riley · Half Upon a Time #2

A fast-moving fairy-tale mashup sequel where Jack and May hop worlds to chase down truth, villains, and their own hidden histories.

Kid
66
Parent
60
Teacher
60
Best fit: ages 10-12 Still works: ages 9-13 Lexile 800L

The story

Book 2 of the Half Upon a Time trilogy picks up with Jack and May thrown into new corners of the fairy-tale multiverse — from the Eye of the Beholder to giant-haunted realms — as old enemies circle and old identities unravel. Expect sarcastic banter, dragon rides, fairy-tale characters behaving badly, and a plot that keeps pulling the rug out.

Age verdict

best 10-12

Our take

page_turner

What stands out

Each audience's top 3 dimensions. Out of 30 scored per book.

👦

Kids love

  • First-chapter grab Strong

    Opens with Jack and the Wolf King dueling mid-flight on a dragon's back, then crashes into the Eye of the Beholder — hook moves faster than Wings of Fire Book 1 and lands multiple reveals inside the first chapter.

  • Character voice Strong

    Jack's sarcastic-deadpan interiority bounces off May's modern snark and the Wolf King's mock-courtly menace; three distinct voices you can identify from one line, like The Lightning Thief's Percy plus two foils.

👩

Parents love

  • Stereotype-breaker Strong

    May is an active quest-partner (not rescued), the fairy-tale princesses are revealed as layered political agents, and Jack's heroism is repeatedly undercut by his own doubts — stronger gender-stereotype breaking than Book 1.

  • Moral reasoning Strong

    Multiple chapters turn on Jack weighing loyalty (to father, to May, to the Wolf King's dying request) against self-interest; the book rewards genuine deliberation over binary choices, similar to The Giver's moral pressure.

🍎

Teachers love

  • Discussion fuel Strong

    Questions about identity, loyalty, rewriting inherited stories, and whether villains can be redeemed generate rich discussion across multiple chapters; reliably fuels 30-minute conversations like A Wrinkle in Time.

  • Writing prompt potential Strong

    Fairy-tale mashup premise naturally prompts 'rewrite a tale with your own spin' and 'what would happen if these two characters met' assignments, strong generative scaffolding like The School for Good and Evil.

✓ Perfect for

  • kids who loved Book 1 and want more of the same crew
  • fans of The School for Good and Evil and Fablehaven
  • readers who enjoy sarcastic-deadpan humor against high-fantasy stakes
  • ages 10-12 comfortable with multi-POV quest fantasy

Not ideal for

readers who haven't read Book 1 (too many callbacks), kids seeking standalone endings, or families avoiding fantasy violence and scary supernatural content

⚠ Heads up

Violence Scary Supernatural Abandonment

At a glance

Pages
384
Chapters
45
Words
70k
Lexile
800L
Difficulty
Moderate
POV
Third Person Limited
Illustration
None
Published
2012
Publisher
Aladdin

Mood & style

Tone: Adventurous Pacing: Steady Clip Weight: Moderate Tension: Time Pressure Humor: Sarcastic Deadpan Humor: Situational

You'll know it worked when…

strong for series-committed readers, soft as standalone

More like this

Same genre, similar age range. Ranked by kid score.

Want more picks like this?

Get 5 hand-picked book reviews for your child's age — one email a month.