← All Books comedy Chapter Book Fully Reviewed

Miss Daisy Is Crazy!

by Dan Gutman · My Weird School #1

The series opener that built a genre — A.J.'s loud kid-voice + a teacher who won't act like one.

Kid
68
Parent
49
Teacher
61
Best fit: ages 7-9 Still works: ages 6-10 Lexile 700L

The story

Second-grader A.J. hates school. Then Miss Daisy arrives — a brand-new teacher who cheerfully admits she can't read, can't do math, and would rather be anywhere else. A.J.'s class sets out to teach her, and along the way Principal Klutz bets his bald head on a million-page reading challenge. Jim Paillot's cartoon illustrations and Dan Gutman's first-person-kid narration launch the 21-book My Weird School series.

Age verdict

Best at ages 7–9 (grades 2–3); still works at 6 with parent support and at 10 for reluctant readers.

Our take

Kid-magnet humor engine: front-loaded laughs and voice, thin on emotional depth, with above-genre classroom utility thanks to a heavy lesson-plan footprint.

What stands out

Each audience's top 3 dimensions. Out of 30 scored per book.

👦

Kids love

  • Laugh-out-loud Exceptional

    Humor engine fires five or six modes on nearly every page — dramatic irony in how Miss Daisy runs the classroom, A.J.'s faulty logic played straight, authority-figure inversion (bald principal in a gorilla suit, Ch11), wordplay ('R-e-e-d,' Ch3), slapstick (Michael spinning till he throws up, Ch5) — AND the entire book is structured around a single sustained dramatic-irony engine that Don't Let the Pigeon Drive the Bus! (9) uses at page-length. Above Babymouse #20 (8) for channel density, matching Pigeon's 9-tier signature of 'sustained laughter through dramatic irony,' below Dog Man's five-channel-plus-Flip-O-Rama 10.

  • Middle momentum Strong

    Twelve chapters averaging ~535 words each, each ending on a pivot or punchline (Ch5 Michael throwing up, Ch7 Miss Daisy eating the bonbons, Ch8 the million-page challenge, Ch10 Boomer's visit) — no sag, and the middle chapters accelerate rather than coast. Matches Captain Underpants #2 (8) for relentless chapter-to-chapter pull in a short chapter-book page budget.

👩

Parents love

  • Reading gateway Strong

    Short 84-page chapter book with 12 micro-chapters of ~535 words, Jim Paillot illustrations, Scholastic book-fair placement, 60+ documented lesson plans, and a first-person voice that speaks directly to reluctant readers. Matches A Bear Called Paddington (8) — a foundational gateway for kids stepping out of early readers; just below Frog and Toad Together (9). Floor P7≥6 triggered by book-fair + multiple reading-list presence.

  • Re-read durability Solid

    Short chapters invite re-visits to favourite set-pieces (Ch5 spin-till-you-throw-up recess contest, Ch7 bonbons, Ch11 gorilla suit), and the catchphrase structure rewards familiarity. Decent for a 6400-word book; kids who love Book 1 typically read twelve to twenty installments, and individual chapters survive repeat read-alouds well.

🍎

Teachers love

  • Reluctant reader rescue Strong

    84-page length, 12 micro-chapters, dialogue-forward pages, Paillot spot illustrations, book-fair ubiquity, and a first-person voice that tells reluctant readers 'school is dumb — but this book isn't' together make this a textbook rescue title. Matches Babymouse #20 (8) and sits just below Wimpy Kid: Hard Luck (9). Gate floor T9≥6 triggered by book-fair + 2+ reading-list presence; artistic judgment escalates to 8.

  • Read-aloud power Strong

    First-person voice performs naturally aloud, dialogue-heavy chapters average ~535 words (ideal 8–10 minute read-aloud units), and the running catchphrases give the reader repeatable bits kids start chanting along. Matches HP2 anchor (8)-adjacent for chapter-book read-aloud fit; a go-to grades 2–3 classroom read.

✓ Perfect for

  • Reluctant grade-2 and grade-3 readers who need a book that speaks their language
  • Kids transitioning out of early readers (Frog and Toad, Mercy Watson) into chapter books
  • Book-fair shoppers looking for a gateway series with plenty of follow-ups
  • Classrooms running dramatic-irony or first-person-voice mini-lessons
  • Read-aloud families with ages 5–9 who want a genuinely funny bedtime book

Not ideal for

Readers looking for emotional depth, literary prose, or quiet stories — the book is deliberately loud, silly, and comedy-first. Parents sensitive to 'dumb'/'crazy' used as character descriptors, or to outdated weight-humor jokes played as A.J.'s faulty logic, may want to pre-read.

At a glance

Pages
84
Chapters
12
Words
6k
Lexile
700L
Difficulty
Easy
POV
First Person
Illustration
Moderate
Published
2004
Illustrator
Jim Paillot

Mood & style

Tone: Comedic Pacing: Rapid Fire Weight: Light Tension: Social Threat Humor: Absurdist Humor: Self Deprecating

You'll know it worked when…

The 21-book series indicates strong kid completion — children who finish Book 1 typically request Book 2 within a week, and many read ten-plus installments before moving on.

More like this

Same genre, similar age range. Ranked by kid score.

Want more picks like this?

Get 5 hand-picked book reviews for your child's age — one email a month.