← All Books mystery Chapter Book Fully Reviewed

The Impossible Crime

by Mac Barnett · Mac B., Kid Spy #2

A clever locked-room mystery wrapped in comedy and real British history

Kid
64
Parent
48
Teacher
58
Best fit: ages 7-10 Still works: ages 6-12 Lexile 440L

The story

When the Queen of England calls young Mac to help guard the Crown Jewels, he finds himself locked in a room at the Tower of London with a grumpy beefeater. But when the jewels vanish from inside the sealed room, Mac must use his spy skills — and some unexpected history lessons — to figure out how the impossible crime was committed.

Age verdict

Best for ages 7-10. The humor, illustrations, and accessible reading level hit the sweet spot for this age range. Older readers may find it too light.

Our take

crowd-pleaser

What stands out

Each audience's top 3 dimensions. Out of 30 scored per book.

👦

Kids love

  • First-chapter grab Strong

    Mac's arcade opening drops readers into a real 1989 California mini-golf course before the Queen's phone call arrives within pages — the spy-mission hook fires faster than most chapter books, comparable to Lunch Lady's cafeteria opening (8) but slightly less immediate since the mission briefing takes a full chapter to develop.

  • Middle momentum Strong

    Twenty-four short chapters maintain relay-race momentum — each chapter ends on a hook or punchline, and the locked-room mystery creates a sustained need-to-know pull through the middle third, similar to Breakout's ticking-clock structure (7) with built-in chapter-end suspense.

👩

Parents love

  • Reading gateway Strong

    Short illustrated chapters, immediate spy-mission hook, constant humor, and low Lexile create one of the strongest gateway experiences for ages 7-10 — similar to A Bear Called Paddington's accessible entry point (8) with even more visual support and contemporary appeal.

  • Real-world window Strong

    Exceptionally strong real-world content for a comedy — Colonel Blood's actual 1671 heist, Tower of London geography, beefeater history, Crown Jewels facts, and 1989 arcade culture are woven naturally into the spy narrative, comparable to Brian's Winter's wilderness ecology (7).

🍎

Teachers love

  • Read-aloud power Strong

    The short chapters, performable dialogue, built-in humor beats, and dramatic mystery tension make this an excellent classroom read-aloud — the Queen's voice and Holcroft's passionate speeches are particularly performable, comparable to The Golem's Eye's dramatic timing (7).

  • Reluctant reader rescue Strong

    Short illustrated chapters, constant humor, spy premise, and low reading level create strong reluctant-reader appeal for ages 7-10 — the mystery hook adds need-to-know motivation beyond humor alone, comparable to Alma's barrier-free format (7).

✓ Perfect for

  • Reluctant readers who need short chapters and constant humor
  • Kids fascinated by spies, mysteries, and real history
  • Readers transitioning from graphic novels to chapter books
  • Ages 7-10 who love absurd humor with a clever mystery underneath

Not ideal for

Readers seeking deep emotional journeys or character-driven drama — this book prioritizes laughs and puzzle-solving over feelings.

At a glance

Pages
149
Chapters
24
Words
12k
Lexile
440L
Difficulty
Easy
POV
First Person
Illustration
Heavy
Published
2019
Publisher
Orchard Books
Illustrator
Mike Lowery
ISBN
9781338143683

Mood & style

Tone: Playful Pacing: Rapid Fire Weight: Light Tension: Mystery Puzzle Humor: Situational Humor: Wordplay

You'll know it worked when…

Most kids will finish this in one or two sittings — the short chapters and mystery hook make it hard to put down.

More like this

Same genre, similar age range. Ranked by kid score.

Want more picks like this?

Get 5 hand-picked book reviews for your child's age — one email a month.