← All Books adventure Ya Novel Fully Reviewed

Evil Star

by Anthony Horowitz · The Power of Five #2

A telekinetic fourteen-year-old is sent to Peru to find a missing Gatekeeper — and runs into a billionaire who knows exactly what he is.

Kid
68
Parent
62
Teacher
56
Best fit: ages 11-14 Still works: ages 10-16 Lexile 680L

The story

The second Power of Five installment doubles the mythology: Matt Freeman, still learning to control his abilities, must find a second Gatekeeper hidden among the waste-pickers of Lima while a corporate-occult enemy races to open an ancient gate in the Nazca Desert. Horowitz pushes the series from British gothic into a globe-spanning paranormal thriller, with real Peruvian geography (Cuzco, the Paracas coast, the Nazca Lines) doing heavy atmospheric work.

Age verdict

Best for 11-14. Advertised 9-12 but the content is decidedly young-YA — parents of sensitive 9-10 year olds should pre-read or wait a year or two.

Our take

Kid-favored thriller: high kid engagement on hook/momentum/surprise with strong but heavy parent/teacher classroom friction

What stands out

Each audience's top 3 dimensions. Out of 30 scored per book.

👦

Kids love

  • Plot unpredictability Exceptional

    Horowitz stacks identity reversals, unreliable magical tools, and shifting allegiances inside the Nexus council so that readers keep having to re-evaluate who and what to trust — closer to Mockingjay (9) for the force of its surprises than Artemis Fowl (8) for stacked smaller reversals.

  • First-chapter grab Strong

    Horowitz opens with a chandelier explosion in a Yorkshire school hall then hands chapter 2 to a disturbed adult on a suicide-driving mission; stronger hook than the Hatchery tour in Brave New World (6) and closer to A Court of Mist and Fury (9) for immediate dread, though not at Artemis Fowl (10) playful mastery.

👩

Parents love

  • Real-world window Strong

    Real geography and sociology do heavy lifting: the Lima waste-picker community, Peruvian police corruption, the Paracas coast, the Nazca Lines, Inti Raymi, post-conquest Inca history; broader real-world window than Brian's Winter (7) ecology and closer to Earthquake in the Early Morning (8) for documentary grounding within a fiction frame.

  • Creative spark Strong

    The book is full of imaginative seeds a kid writer can steal — a doorway that teleports across continents, a desert glyph used as a celestial combination-lock, a bird used as an assassin, flies that coalesce into soldiers; creative-spark density rivals InvestiGators: Off the Hook (10) for a prose novel.

🍎

Teachers love

  • Cross-curricular value Strong

    Real cross-curricular payoff in astronomy (Cygnus, stellar alignment), archaeology (Nazca, Vilcabamba), geography (Paracas coast, Cuzco), history (Inca resistance after 1533), and civics (urban poverty, police corruption); denser than A Deadly Education (7) on cross-curricular hooks, below A Wolf Called Wander (10) because the science is applied, not studied.

  • Mentor text quality Solid

    The three-chapter opening is a strong mentor text for escalating-hook technique and POV-switch handoffs, and the ending takes a structural risk worth dissecting in a writing workshop; comparable to Frog and Toad Together (6) for teachable moments in one narrow dimension.

✓ Perfect for

  • readers who loved Artemis Fowl, Alex Rider, or Percy Jackson's darker moments
  • older reluctant readers who want thriller pacing with approachable prose
  • children fascinated by Inca history, the Nazca Lines, or ancient mysteries
  • fans who finished Raven's Gate and want the world to get bigger

Not ideal for

Younger or more sensitive readers bothered by on-page violence, multiple deaths, body horror, and cosmic-horror imagery; children who prefer neatly resolved endings.

⚠ Heads up

Violence Death Scary Supernatural Mature Themes Poverty Abandonment

At a glance

Pages
368
Chapters
21
Words
85k
Lexile
680L
Difficulty
Moderate
POV
Third Person Limited
Illustration
None
Published
2006
Publisher
Walker Books

Mood & style

Tone: Dark Pacing: Rollercoaster Weight: Heavy Tension: Supernatural Threat Humor: None

You'll know it worked when…

Ends on a coda that explicitly sets up Book 3 (Nightrise) — this is a middle book in a tightly plotted five-book arc.

More like this

Same genre, similar age range. Ranked by kid score.

Want more picks like this?

Get 5 hand-picked book reviews for your child's age — one email a month.