← All Books mystery Middle Grade Novel Fully Reviewed

Enola Holmes: The Case of the Left-Handed Lady

by Nancy Springer · Enola Holmes Mysteries #2

A fourteen-year-old girl outsmarts Sherlock Holmes — and Victorian London — in Book 2 of the series behind the Netflix movie.

Kid
68
Parent
80
Teacher
77
Best fit: ages 11-13 Still works: ages 10-15 for strong readers Lexile 980L

The story

Hiding in London as 'Ivy Meshle,' assistant to the fictitious perditorian Dr. Ragostin, Enola Holmes takes on the case of missing aristocrat Lady Cecily Alistair. Cecily's charcoal drawings — done with her left hand, the hand her family forbids — lead Enola into a network of suffragettes, a dying radical's final hours, a garrote attack in a London alley, and a rooftop rescue from her own family's attic cell. All while evading Sherlock, who is closing in on his runaway sister one deduction at a time.

Age verdict

Sweet spot 11-13. Strong 10-year-olds with historical-fiction experience can handle it; 9 is a stretch.

Our take

A grown-up mystery: parents and teachers see more here than kids do. The Victorian register, suffragette history, and bittersweet ambiguity reward readers with stamina; the strong-girl-outsmarts-Sherlock hook is the kid entry point.

What stands out

Each audience's top 3 dimensions. Out of 30 scored per book.

👦

Kids love

  • Character voice Strong

    Enola's first-person voice is unmistakable: dry, self-deprecating wit about her 'figurines' (bust improvers hiding supplies), candid about loneliness hiding in Mrs. Tupper's boardinghouse, fiercely pragmatic about disguise — a voice distinct enough that readers who know Book 1 recognize her in a sentence.

  • Mental movie Strong

    1889 London is painted in sharp, sensory detail — fog on Baker Street, the gas-lit Alistair drawing room, the cramped attic cell with its one window, Enola's Dr. Ragostin office with its false nameplate — every location lodges as a specific picture, aided by Springer's eye for period texture (crinolines, calling cards, perditorian shingles).

👩

Parents love

  • Vocabulary builder Exceptional

    Exceptional period vocabulary load: perditorian, garrote, crinoline, calling card, suffragette, Tyburn, smelling salts, bustle, boarding house, matchgirl, mesmerism — plus Victorian register phrasings ('I took the liberty,' 'I am persuaded') threaded through Enola's narration; rich enough to be a genuine word-growth book.

  • Stereotype-breaker Exceptional

    Enola, at 14, opens her own perditorian practice under a male pseudonym ('Dr. Ragostin') to outsmart Sherlock Holmes himself — the book's spine is women finding ways through a system designed to erase them (Cecily's radical drawings, the dying suffragette, Enola's runaway independence), not tacked-on girl-power but structural.

🍎

Teachers love

  • Cross-curricular value Exceptional

    Touches history (suffragette movement, 1880s London), social studies (women's legal status, asylum reform), art (Cecily's left-handed drawings as coded protest), literature (Sherlock Holmes canon), and vocabulary (period English) — few MG titles hit five disciplines this cleanly.

  • Classroom versatility Strong

    Fits cleanly into mystery units, Victorian-era historical fiction units, women's history month, and introduction-to-Sherlock units; the series installment nature (Book 2) means it pairs naturally with Book 1 as a compare-contrast, and the Netflix tie-in gives film-vs-book lesson hooks.

✓ Perfect for

  • strong readers 11-14 who want history with teeth
  • girls hungry for a protagonist who never asks permission
  • Sherlock Holmes fans ready for a fresh angle
  • kids who came to the series via the Netflix movie and can handle denser prose
  • mystery lovers ready to graduate from Encyclopedia Brown

Not ideal for

Reluctant readers, kids under 10, and readers who prefer light or purely comedic adventure — the Victorian register and the somber suffragette thread ask for stamina and a willingness to sit with ambiguity.

⚠ Heads up

Violence Death Mature Themes

At a glance

Pages
234
Chapters
17
Words
45k
Lexile
980L
Difficulty
Challenging
POV
First Person
Illustration
None
Published
2007

Mood & style

Tone: Suspenseful Pacing: Measured Weight: Moderate Tension: Mystery Puzzle Humor: Gentle Wit Humor: Situational

You'll know it worked when…

Readers who finish typically race to Book 3. The Netflix-movie viewer who powers through Ch 1-3 will stay for the rest.

More like this

Same genre, similar age range. Ranked by kid score.

Want more picks like this?

Get 5 hand-picked book reviews for your child's age — one email a month.