I Love My New Toy!
by Mo Willems · Elephant & Piggie
A masterclass in friendship and forgiveness, told in 300 perfectly chosen words
Kid
68
/ 100
Parent
58
/ 100
Teacher
65
/ 100
Best fit: ages Ages 4-7
Still works: ages Ages 3-9
Our Take
A kid-favored picture book that excels at engagement and accessibility (K1, K3, K6, K8 all 8+) while providing strong teaching value (T1, T9 both 9). The parent scorecard reflects the format's inherent limitations in vocabulary and real-world content, offset by exceptional gateway power and solid conversation-starting potential.
✓ Perfect for
- • Emerging readers ready for their first independent book
- • Children learning about friendship, sharing, and handling conflict
- • Read-aloud sessions that want genuine emotional engagement in under 5 minutes
- • Reluctant readers who need a zero-barrier entry point
Book facts
- Format
- picture book
- ISBN
- 9781423109617
- Series
- Elephant & Piggie
- Illustration
- fully_illustrated
More like I Love My New Toy!
Same genre, similar age range. Ranked by kid score.
Want more picks like this?
Get 5 hand-picked book reviews for your child's age — one email a month.